- FMA
- The Fabricator
- FABTECH
- Canadian Metalworking
Categories
- Additive Manufacturing
- Aluminum Welding
- Arc Welding
- Assembly and Joining
- Automation and Robotics
- Bending and Forming
- Consumables
- Cutting and Weld Prep
- Electric Vehicles
- En Español
- Finishing
- Hydroforming
- Laser Cutting
- Laser Welding
- Machining
- Manufacturing Software
- Materials Handling
- Metals/Materials
- Oxyfuel Cutting
- Plasma Cutting
- Power Tools
- Punching and Other Holemaking
- Roll Forming
- Safety
- Sawing
- Shearing
- Shop Management
- Testing and Measuring
- Tube and Pipe Fabrication
- Tube and Pipe Production
- Waterjet Cutting
Industry Directory
Webcasts
Podcasts
FAB 40
Advertise
Subscribe
Account Login
Search
It's all about tool selection -- or is it?
- By Steve Benson
- May 10, 2005
- Article
- Bending and Forming
Figure 1 The radius gauge fits squarely into the bend. |
Air forming, bottom bending, and coining are different forming methods that can be used to create various bends—sharp, radius, and profound-radius. Throw in a mix of operators and engineers with different ideas of what each method is and how each is applied, and confusion about the best way to accomplish a task might arise.
In forming operations, no matter how operators and engineers with different ideas make the project work, who is right and who is wrong is no mystery. They all are correct to some extent.
Say what? Yes, they are all correct to some extent. Take for example the fact that a 90-degree punch mated with a 90-degree V die can be used to air-form, bottom-bend, and coin. Each method will produce a different inside radius and bend deduction; however, all three methods can use a single tool set.
Making the right tooling selection requires understanding what tools you have on the shop floor. It also means understanding what methods your press brake operators are using. Are they air forming? Are they bottom bending? Are they coining? Or are they using some combination of all three? Most likely, it's the latter.
So how do you make competent tool selections at the design stage before the job gets to the shop floor? By asking your experts—those who work the machines daily. It's important that you know your facility's capabilities and understand the methods used.
This leads us then to question how to best deal with that information.
A Is A
First let's look at the inside bend radius, the basis for laying out any sheet metal part. By getting incorrect information at this point, if not fatal, it will at the very least be an expensive lesson. In a speech from Atlas Shrugged, John Galt states that "A is A," and nothing else but A can be A. Isn't it time to look at your shop situation from the same objectivistic viewpoint? In doing so you will find that not only is A, A, but also that a 1/32-inch inside bend radius is a 1/32-inch inside bend radius.
All too often the inside radius specified on a blueprint is never achieved. Just because a punch with the desired radius is used to produce the bend doesn't mean that the required radius is achieved. Shop floor forming method variations and tool selection errors can produce poor, unusable parts.
Many times the inside bend radius isn't verified with a radius gauge (Figure 1). When some operators use bottom bending and others use air forming—occasionally to produce the same part—wide deviations in inside bend radii can occur. Because the bend deduction (BD) or K factor is derived from the inside bend radius, not achieving "A" (the required inside bend radius) manifests itself as inconsistent parts over time.
When methods and tool selection differ from operator to operator, so do the results. When your efforts to get the press brake operators to use a common system fail, that's when you need to remember John Galt's "A is A." A 1/32-inch inside bend radius is a 1/32-inch inside bend radius, regardless of how it's achieved. When the required 1/32 inside radius is a 1/32 inside radius, A equals A, and the part is good.
Understanding Your Shop's Abilities
Does your shop have a variety of tools? Does it seem that no two operators use the same tooling in the same situation? Almost every bend other than a 90-degree bend is by default air-formed, and with air forming, every variation in the V-die opening increases or decreases the inside radius. When a part is bottom-bent or coined, the radius is stamped into the material.
The only deviation from the air forming default for angles other than 90 degrees is when sharp bend radii are required—a sharp bend less than 63 percent of the material thickness. Air forming cannot produce a sharp bend. Instead, it creates a ditch in the bottom of the bend, amplifying all variables within the material—thickness, hardness, and grain direction—while producing a radius derived from the V-die opening.
For bottom bending, the minimum inside radius is no less than 63 percent of the material thickness. Coining is not recommended for sharp bending. Whether the machine is new or old, it is too tonnage-intensive.
Your engineering or design department simply needs to specify an inside radius that you already have confirmed is within your shop's abilities. Insist that quality control verify that the calculated inside radii have been met with the radius gauge sitting squarely in the radius. When this is the case, the bend's mathematics have been achieved.
Assuming you have the tooling that can produce the desired inside bend radii, selecting the forming method and tooling on the shop floor cease to be issues. Air form, bottom bend, or coin as long as A is A. You'll make high-quality parts.
About the Author
Steve Benson
2952 Doaks Ferry Road N.W.
Salem, OR 97301-4468
503-399-7514
Related Companies
subscribe now
The Fabricator is North America's leading magazine for the metal forming and fabricating industry. The magazine delivers the news, technical articles, and case histories that enable fabricators to do their jobs more efficiently. The Fabricator has served the industry since 1970.
start your free subscription- Stay connected from anywhere
Easily access valuable industry resources now with full access to the digital edition of The Fabricator.
Easily access valuable industry resources now with full access to the digital edition of The Welder.
Easily access valuable industry resources now with full access to the digital edition of The Tube and Pipe Journal.
Easily access valuable industry resources now with full access to the digital edition of The Fabricator en Español.
- Podcasting
- Podcast:
- The Fabricator Podcast
- Published:
- 03/26/2024
- Running Time:
- 67:51
This week on The Fabricator Podcast, Jason Becker, host of the Arc Junkies Podcast and owner of Underground...
- Trending Articles
USS Midway’s tuition-free welding program a win-win
San Diego landmark becomes floating classroom for student welders
K&S celebrates 50 years in business
Guiding metal fabrication’s automation transformation
Increasing revenue by applying production concepts to sales and marketing
- Industry Events
Coil Processing Workshop & Tours
- April 2 - 3, 2024
- Corpus Christi, TX
GOLF4MFG South
- April 15, 2024
- Charlotte, NC
16th Annual Safety Conference
- April 30 - May 1, 2024
- Elgin,
Pipe and Tube Conference
- May 21 - 22, 2024
- Omaha, NE
World-Class Roll Forming Workshop
- June 5 - 6, 2024
- Louisville, KY